Letters From Iwo Jima (2006) 8/10
In 1945, 22,000 Japanese soldiers defended the small, ash covered island of Iwo Jima from a 100,000 strong US invasion force. 6,821 Americans were killed and 20,000 wounded, while only 1,083 Japanese survived the battle. In Clint Eastwood’s Flags of Our Fathers, the battle of iwo jima was seen through the American perspective. However, the focus on the Rosenthal photograph, and the intercutting of weaker scenes in America with the stronger Iwo Jima portion blunted the force of the film. In his companion film Letters of Iwo Jima, Eastwood sets the film almost entirely on that small, bleak island (about 5 miles long) and the result is a powerful, humanistic war film that is not only one of the best films of 2006, but also one of the best war films ever made.
Like Flags, Letters is filmed in monochromatic hues which almost approximates black and white, giving a distinct documentary feel to it. Ken Watanbe impresses as Gen. Kuribayashi, an astute leader who fights an impassioned but ultimately futile battle. The tale of soldiers fighting a losing battle is as timeless as it is poignant. Going beyond the typical caricature of Japanese soliders, Eastwood highlights the similarity rather than the differences between the Americans and the Japanese. And in so doing, he shows the ultimate futility of war. The film is not so much about the war (the amount of combat sequences are relatively few), but more about the characters. With a fine cast headlined by Watanbe, and a stirring soundtrack with brilliant cinematography, Letters is a laudable accomplishment.
Definately a notch better than Flags, Letters is also Eastwood’s most earnest and brilliant film in years. While he has received more awards for his earlier films like Million Dollar Baby or Mystic River, it is the challenge of filming in another language that has truly brought out the best in Eastwood. While parts of the film overdoses on sentimentality, and the occasional flashbacks to Japan or America feels unnecessary, the film postively soars when it stays on focus in Iwo Jima.
‘”Letters” represents filmmaking so assured it can take your breath away.’- Boston Globe
“Clint gives humanity to the soldiers who have been considered, until now, the enemy. He shows them to be men and not just a faceless opponent. “- Reeling Reviews
“As opposed to its more-ambitious companion piece, which soured the mix with themes about fabricating heroes, Letters is spare, simple and claustrophobic — pure drama, and possibly Clint Eastwood’s best film.”- Slotek